United Nations
Disabled Persons Bulletin
Bulletin No 2 of 1998
Page 4/7
Application of international conventions, standards and norms to domestic law
Application of international law
Translation from an international convention, standard or norm to national law and then
to local implementation is slow and complex but of primary importance. States are the
major instrument in transforming certain legislative, administrative and judicial
practices, which empower persons with disabilities to vindicate their rights. States that
have become Parties to an international convention are legally bound to implement the
provisions contained in the convention in their domestic jurisdiction. International law
leaves it to States to adopt such legislative and other measures, consistent with their
constitutional processes, to give effect to the obligations which they undertake to
implement and ensure that any person whose rights or freedoms are violated have an
effective remedy justifiable before independent and impartial tribunals.
Three main methods are available to implement international legal instruments in
domestic law:
- Direct incorporation of rights recognized in the international instrument into what may
be termed a "bill of rights" in the national legal order;
- Enactment of different legislative measures in the civil, criminal and administrative
laws to give effect to the rights recognized in international legal instruments;
- Self-executing operation of international legal instruments in the national legal order.
The course of the legislative process will differ according to the relevant domestic
legal systems. For instance, incorporation of international human rights principles and
norms in national constitutions - or similar documents - remains the most important way of
bringing national laws in conformity with international standards.
Direct application of international law by domestic courts can also play an important
role in implementing international human rights norms applicable to persons with
disabilities by means of compliance with relevant international standards and citing
precedents in other jurisdictions. Due process of law has to be followed in matters of
disability legislation.
Furthermore, judicial initiatives may propel executive and legislative branches of
Governments to act with regard to drafting, enforcing and evaluating disability
legislation.
Role of domestic courts: incorporation of international norms and standards by
domestic courts
Domestic courts can play a major role in interpreting and developing international
standards and norms. As much as national courts can serve as an effective mechanism for
the protection and extension of the rights of citizens, courts can play a major role in
applying international standards in domestic issues of disability. Courts also may bring
matters to legislative attention and encourage various interest groups to take up action
on certain issues. The greater the extent to which international norms on disability are
widely known, the greater the possibility of domestic courts complying with these norms.
National courts could become a forum for the promotion and protection of international
human rights of persons with disabilities. National courts could also contribute to the
establishment of an agenda for the creation of national legislation in harmony with all
other pertinent international norms and mobilize governmental and non-governmental action
in support of equal opportunities for persons with disabilities.
Even if adoption of national legislation does not always ensure that individuals have
recourse against violations of rights contained in international human rights instruments,
the general character of treaty provisions makes it advisable for these instruments to be
implemented by specific detailed provisions in domestic law.
|